UFPG RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED THAT:
1. Clear-felling should be suspended
2. The agreement with CTR be investigated
UFPG addressed the delegates on biodiversity and the fact that SANPARKS chooses to ignore the qualification of sustainability. The most important point made by him was that whilst the Minister may have entered into a lease with SANPARKS, the Minister had not abrogated her right to amend the conditions of the permit to conduct forestry industry on state land.
There was further discussion and the meeting ended on a good note with the parties agreeing that the matter was urgent in that tree-felling is continuing at a swift pace and that there was a danger that whilst we were discussing the next steps to be taken the public may be left with areas of the mountains laid bare with the dangers of soil erosion once the winter sets in.
some more highly respected opinions and quotes...
Cape Times 14 Aug 2006 - Prof. George Ellis, recently awarded a Fellowship in the prestigious Royal Society, wrote: "Review Tree Policy" - "the plantations..are small but important assets to the urban park and can best serve the citizens of Cape Town as working plantations"
Cape Times 9 Feb 2007: Prof Eugene
Moll affirms: "SANParks Felling Many Trees
Which Have Great Cultural Value": "...the plantations provide great
value in amenities and scenery to the city, as well as value in
providing timber".
Cape Times 30 March": indigenous botanist Marijke
Honig pleads: "Alien tree annihilation should not consume
conservationists": ....the cultural & recreational value
of...plantations...far outweighs its conservation value".
Finally, Prof Emeritus R. Fuggle's "The Multipurpose
Use of the Cape Peninsula" - Fuggle, Siegfried & Raimondo, UCT
Environmental Evaluation Unit,1994 states: "Tokai is financially
viable...Cecilia & Newlands forests are effectively managed for
recreational purposes only, and are considered distinctive
components of the Peninsula's landscape".
We would like to add that SANParks, Dept Water Affairs & Forestry,
Dept of Environmental Affairs & Tourism and Table Mountain National
Park, are currently studying various options to balance the very
different, but inter-acting interests of bio-diversity, environment
& recreation in the context of an Urban National Park.
Environmental Issues of Cape Town
More or Less
Jobs ?
The
Future
An Urban Park for All
The Media
Copyright
Urban Forest Protection Group