Breaking News Home

Help us to Save our Forests

Politics

After Urban Forest Protection Group (UFPG) had threatened to take legal action the Department of Water Affairs and Forestry in the very last moment offered to meet us. The meeting with a delegation of the DWAF took place on March 29th at the offices of TMNP in West Lake Business Park.
Richard Machaba was duly delegated as Chairman of the meeting and he introduced his fellow delegates and then advised th  following :
  • Whatever the Government undertakes, it does so in the interest of the people of South Africa.

     The importance of the meeting can be gauged by virtue of the high level of delegation which the Minister of Forestry has sent to attend it.

    The matter being discussed at the meeting is taken most seriously.

    He stated that consensus was needed for an amicable solution.

    The Department will not procrastinate on this matter and will seek early solution and he undertook that the Urban Forest Group delegation would hear from the Government delegates within the next 6 weeks.


    Despite MTO delegates not being present, the delegates representing Government would engage with them on the subject being dealt with.

     
    The Urban Protection Group then put their concerns to the Government delegation and handed in documentation drawn up by  various committee members .  UFPG put questions to the Forestry representatives as follows:
     
    No public participation of consultation process had been initiated.
     
    The decision does not comply with NEMA, nor with PAJA
     
    No EIA was carried out
     
    The exit lease agreement with Cape Timber Resources, a key factor in the decision, was made.without public bidding.
     
    MTO Forestry is opposed to the current programme.
     
    There has been a public outcry which has been expressed in Cape Media over the past 9 months .regarding this issue which is quite unacceptable both socially and also against the principles of ourConstitution. 

UFPG RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED THAT:
 
            1.         Clear-felling should be suspended
 
            2.         The agreement with CTR be investigated
 
 
UFPG addressed the delegates on biodiversity and the fact that SANPARKS chooses to ignore the qualification of sustainability. The most important point made by him was that whilst the Minister may have entered into a lease with  SANPARKS, the Minister had not abrogated her right to amend the conditions of the permit to conduct forestry industry on state land.
 
There was further discussion and the meeting ended on a good note with the parties agreeing that the matter was urgent in that tree-felling is continuing at a swift pace and that there was a danger that whilst we were discussing the next steps to be taken the public may be left with areas of the mountains laid bare with the dangers of soil erosion once the winter sets in.

some more highly respected opinions and quotes...

Cape Times 14 Aug 2006  - Prof. George Ellis, recently awarded  a Fellowship in the prestigious Royal Society, wrote: "Review Tree Policy" - "the plantations..are small but important assets to the urban park and can best serve the citizens of Cape Town as working plantations"


Cape Times 9 Feb 2007: Prof Eugene Moll affirms: "SANParks Felling Many Trees Which Have Great Cultural Value":  "...the plantations provide great value in amenities and scenery to the city, as well as value in providing timber".


Cape Times 30 March": indigenous botanist Marijke Honig pleads: "Alien tree annihilation should not consume conservationists": ....the cultural & recreational value of...plantations...far outweighs its conservation value".


Finally, Prof Emeritus R. Fuggle's  "The Multipurpose Use of the Cape Peninsula" - Fuggle, Siegfried & Raimondo, UCT Environmental Evaluation Unit,1994 states: "Tokai is financially viable...Cecilia & Newlands forests are effectively managed for recreational purposes only, and are considered distinctive components of the Peninsula's landscape".


We would like to add that SANParks, Dept Water Affairs & Forestry, Dept of Environmental Affairs & Tourism and Table Mountain National Park, are currently studying various options to balance the very different, but inter-acting interests of bio-diversity, environment & recreation in the context of an Urban National Park.

 

 

Environmental Issues of Cape Town

Tree, Forest and Fynbos Myths

Follow The Money

More or Less Jobs ?

The Future

An Urban Park for All

The Media

Picture Proof

Have Your Say

 

Copyright

Urban Forest Protection Group